Home Earth changes Pro-regulatory litigants more likely to win renewable energy than those involving coal-fired...

Pro-regulatory litigants more likely to win renewable energy than those involving coal-fired power plants — ScienceDaily


The courts have played a central role in climate change policy, starting with a landmark Supreme Court case that led to the mandatory regulation of greenhouse gases in the United States. How do the courts address climate cases today? Who wins, who loses and what kinds of strategies make a difference in the courtroom?

Researchers at the George Washington University (GW) have published a study in Nature Climate Change that for the first time analyzes all U.S climate change lawsuits over a 26-year period.

“This first-of-a-kind study outlines the types of climate change lawsuits that are more likely to win or lose, and why,” said lead author Sabrina McCormick, PhD, MA, an Associate Professor of Environmental and Occupational Health at GW’s Milken Institute School of Public Health (Milken Institute SPH). “Efforts to affect U.S. climate change policy should consider current trends in the courtroom.”

McCormick and her colleagues collected and analyzed all climate change cases from 1990 through 2016, for a total of 873 lawsuits. The team also interviewed 78 lawyers, advocates and scientists involved in these cases in order to find out more about the evidence and strategies they typically use in building a case.

The researchers found the most common climate issues brought to court involved coal-fired power plants and other air quality concerns. Litigants asking the courts for more regulations to curb emissions more frequently lost than won such lawsuits, the study found. In such cases, the courts may be swayed by the industry argument that regulations to cut down on emissions will affect a plant’s bottom line, although effects on health and welfare have not been measured.

“At the same time, litigants who want to address climate change often win renewable energy and energy efficiency cases,” McCormick said. “The courts favored the pro-regulatory positions in these kinds of cases by a ratio of 2.6 to 1.”

Such cases may be an underappreciated opportunity for litigants who want more government regulation in the climate change arena, she said.

The study identified four typical goals of pro-regulatory plaintiffs in climate change lawsuits: force government regulators to take steps to reduce greenhouse gases; change corporate behavior; assign responsibility for impacts; and change the public debate.

Strategies that lawyers commonly cited in such lawsuits included the use of climate science and other types of data as well as collaborations to form a coalition of plaintiffs. Such coalitions can be an effective strategy, especially if they include individuals or states who have been harmed by some aspect of climate change, McCormick said.

Winning might not be the only consideration in bringing a lawsuit, said McCormick’s co-author Robert L. Glicksman, JD, the J.B. and Maurice C. Shapiro Professor of Environmental Law at the GW Law School. In some interviews, lawyers said that even if they lost a case, the arguments often lead to greater public awareness of the issues involved with climate change, Glicksman said.

“The Trump Administration’s refusal to even acknowledge human contributions to climate change, no less pursue any meaningful action to mitigate or adapt to it, coupled with Congress’s persistent inaction on climate issues, makes efforts to address climate change in the courts all the more important,” Glicksman said. “Our study assesses how such efforts have fared.”

Story Source:

Materials provided by George Washington University. Note: Content may be edited for style and length.



Source link

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Must Read

Why Website Downtime Occurs and How Website Monitoring Service Can Help

Anyone who owns or operates a website knows that maintaining the uptime of that site is of the utmost importance. Dreaded downtime results in...

Biosolids – A New Vacuum Truck Purpose!

There are several common issues that the world is facing right now. One of these issues has to do with waste management systems. The...

Henosepilachna Vigintioctopunctata: The Hadda Beetle

Insects are the animals dwelling on the planet earth well adapted to survive in all sorts of environments one can imagine. They can survive...

Pro-regulatory litigants more likely to win renewable energy than those involving coal-fired power plants — ScienceDaily

The courts have played a central role in climate change policy, starting with a landmark Supreme Court case that led to the mandatory...

What Are My Channel Options on Sirius Satellite Radio?

Sirius Satellite Radio is more than just music. Some of the 12 million listeners prefer television-like content delivered right to their morning commute to...
Support